Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

So simple. So delicious. So easy.

This recipe is probably not too original although I didn’t get it from anywhere. I just got tired of those little frozen pot pies and put this together one day to see if it would work. The hubby loved it and the kids will actually eat it. So its been a staple for the last 10 years or so. Here, in all its glory is my chicken pot pie.

Chicken Pot Pie mmmm yummy

Don’t hate me because my crust is beautiful. Seriously, don’t hate me. It’s not my crust. Well, not my usual recipe. I found one of those “never fail” crust recipes over at The Pioneer Woman Cooks and finally decided to try it. It does work beautifully, and the recipe makes enough dough for 3 double crust pies. Which means you can make this delicious pot pie and put two crusts in the freezer for later. Who can argue with crust that looks (and tastes) like this, especially when you just have to thaw and roll? It beats the hell out of Pillsbury.

Recipe and more pictures after the jump.

Ok, let’s gather our ingredients. (If you followed the link to The Pioneer Woman Cooks, you will realize that I am shamelessly stealing formatting… I can live with it.)

Chicken pot pie ingredients

You will need

  • 1 1/2 cups cooked chicken (Yes I know mine is raw)
  • Pie crust (feel free to use a purchased crust if you must… cretin)
  • 1 can 15oz mixed vegetables (drained)
  • 1 can 10.75oz cream of chicken soup
  • Salt to taste
  • Pepper to taste
  • Minced onion to taste
  • Cheesy rooster cookie jar in a basket to somehow evoke “chicken in a basket” memories, even though you don’t really have any memories of “chicken in a basket” and sometimes wonder, “What the hell is “chicken in a basket” and why does it always have “quotes” around it?”

First things first

We must cook some chicken to get some cooked chicken. Now, if you already have some cooked chicken, move to the head of the class and get your gold star. You are the teacher’s pet today (look, everybody’s so jealous!). If you are using canned chicken, good for you… leave this blog. This author believes in saving all the time and money possible but even he will not eat two things – canned chicken and Spam. 

There are two reasons why I did not use cooked chicken this time. I wanted to talk to you about the lowly pressure cooker. But mostly, I just didn’t have any cooked chicken. Pressure cooker

Pressure cookers are wonderful things. They cut your cooking time dramatically and they produce juicier, more tender meat. You may not be able to tell from the photo, but these breasts are still mostly frozen. However, unlike the rest of us, the pressure cooker doesn’t care how cold your meat is.

Did I really just type that?

One caveat you must keep in mind when using a pressure cooker – YOU ABSOLUTELY MUST, I MEAN MUST, USE A LIQUID. See the measuring cup with the water? That’s my liquid. You could use chicken broth if you want, it doesn’t matter as long as you have a liquid. A pressure cooker uses steam and pressure to cook foods at very high temperatures. Without a liquid your pressure cooker doesn’t work and may even break. Read your instruction manual for specific directions.

Ok, let’s put the chicken in and get started. Chicken in pressure cookerFirst add your liquid (mine was about 1 1/2 cups water). Then put in the cooking rack – which of course I forgot to photograph. Then lay in your chicken in a nice, single layer if possible. Sprinkle the chicken breasts with salt, pepper, and dried, minced onion.

Here’s a tip: As soon as I add the liquid to the pot, I turn the burner on high so I can get it to a boil as soon as possible. Usually, by the time I’ve got the meat spiced and layered the liquid is boiling or very close to boiling. If you do this, your cooker will “pressure up” much quicker.

Pressure cooker cooking

Now pop the lid on and place the weighted rocker on the vent. Leave your burner on high until the rocker starts to rock. Once the rocker is in motion, turn the burner down to about medium low heat and set your timer. You should read your manual for exact cooking times. My manual says to cook bone-in chicken for 8 minutes but since my breasts were frozen (let it go, let it go) I cooked mine for 15 minutes.

 Cooked chicken

After the cooker has cooled and the pressure lock has released, this is what you will have – delicious cooked chicken, ready to pick.

I used chicken breast this time because Tom Thumb had them on sale for $0.99/pound. I bought 15 pounds and repackaged them in ziplock bags (3 breasts to a bag). You could make this recipe with any chicken that you like or have on hand. Leftover baked chicken is really good in this pie. Be creative.

Pickin chicken

Here’s the results of my chicken pickin’. 1 1/2 cups of chicken for the pie, which is equal to about one breast, and about 3 cups of chicken for future use. Later this week we will have Chicken Enchiladas. Me gusto enchiladas de pollo. And for lunch we’ll have chicken salad. I also got 2 cups of chicken broth.


Goop or chicken pot pie ingredients

Ok poppets, back to your regularly scheduled recipe. Put these things in a bowl

  • Cream of chicken soup
  • Can of mixed vegtables (drained)
  • Cooked chicken
  • 1 or 2 tablespoons of your fresh chicken broth or milk (use just enough to thin out the soup but don’t make it runny)
  • Salt to taste
  • Pepper to taste

Chicken pot pie stuff

Mix it all up until it looks like this. Set it aside while we roll out the dough.




aDividing crust


Sprinkle a generous handful of flour onto a smooth, dry surface. Divide your thawed dough into a top and bottom crust. I divided mine into 1/3 for the top and 2/3 for the bottom. Your division may be different depending on the pan you use.




Bottom crust

Pat the dough into a small square. Flour your rolling pin and roll the dough into a square, rectangle, or circle, depending on your pan. Roll the dough until it will cover the bottom and the sides of your dish. I used a 1 1/2 quart deep casserole so I rolled my dough until it was about 2″ bigger than the bottom of my dish.




Bottom crust in pan

Use your favorite method to transfer the dough to the dish. You can fold it into quarters, roll it onto the rolling pin, however you want. If you’re using a deep casserole like me, be aware, your crust will probably collapse and look like the picture at the right no matter which method you use. It’s ok. That’s why you have fingers. Look in the back right corner of your freezer and get the bottle of Bailey’s Irish Creme that you hide from your husband. Take a drink. Now isn’t that better?



Bottom Crust


Ok hide the bottle before someone sees. Now just use your fingers to pat the dough into place.




Ready for the oven

Dump your bowl of filling into the pie dish. Roll your top crust until it will cover the pie and transfer to the pie dish. Crimp the edges of the crusts together. Now, take a knife and cut slits in the top crust so that the steam can escape. Stick this bad boy into a preheated, 350 degree oven until the crust is golden brown and the filling is bubbling. Mine cooked for about an hour. Yours may take more or less time depending on the depth of your dish but an hour is a good estimate.



Chicken pot pie serving

This will make four servings. We like to add a little butter and grated cheddar cheese (just to make it healthier). Mm-mmm, that’s some good eatin’.


11 thoughts on “Chicken Pot Pie Recipe

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s